# Transcript

**Anand**: [00:01] So testing, one, two, three. Okay, it works. **I was born with the name Anand, which is terrible, actually**. In a typical class, the kids get called on right at the beginning of the class for any homework submission, for any presentation they have. It doesn’t matter what; if they’re alphabetically ahead, it’s a problem. In fact, there was only one of my classmates at IIM Bangalore who was slightly ahead of me; his name was Ajit. I said, "Boss, you’re in trouble." And then he went and named his son Aadi with two A’s. How sadistic can you get?

**Anand**: [00:46] But then, he said, "Look, it actually makes a difference because now, because you’re being called on so early, you’ll actually be much better prepared than us." So many years later, once I became a data scientist and I said, "Look, I need to test data on everything," I said, "Let's put this to the test." So, I took the Karnataka marks for five years starting with 2005. **I found that students whose name begins with the letter A actually are scoring the highest**. It’s not a huge difference, but I mean, there is a difference. And the lowest are people whose name starts with the letter M.

**Anand**: [01:25] So I said, "Okay, but maybe this is just luck, right? Does it change?" After six years when we did the study, it turns out that it doesn't make that much of a difference. A has gone down a little bit, V has gone up a little bit, D is roughly the same, S is roughly the same, R is roughly the same, M is roughly the same—still at the bottom. **So why? Why does this make a difference? Is it really just because I get called on first? I wasn't so sure. I’m still not sure**.

**Anand**: [01:54] We extended this. So we did this in Tamil Nadu and said, "Let's plot the names of all children who took the class 12 exams in 2012, I think." And each of these boxes represents one name. So the big box is all of those who have the name Kumar. Now, the trouble is in Tamil Nadu you can’t really distinguish between first names and last names. So my name is S. Anand. Okay, I mean, what is first name, what is last name? I didn't know until I was 22.

**Anand**: [02:22] So there’s one name, and the most common name that is a part of a person’s name was Kumar, followed by Priya, and so on. And the color of these boxes represents how they score. So, you know, dark blue is higher scores and light blue is lower scores. **So if you look at who really scores well: the Jains, the Shahs, and the Agarwals in Tamil Nadu—just crack it**. The average is 88% as against a state average of 66%, right?

**Anand**: [02:53] Now, who does not—well, okay, and who else does well? We find that names like Shweta, Sneha, Pooja, Harini, Sanjana, Deepti, Varshini—all of them do well. **Classic urban girls' names**. Who does not do well? Manikandan, Venkatesan, Ezhumalai, Silambarasan, Pandian, Kumaresan, Tirupati—**classic rural boys' names**.

**Anand**: [03:13] So you know what's happening here. **It's not that the name makes a difference to the marks; it is that the same socio-economic factors that drive a certain nomenclature are also possibly responsible for the children's performance**. But it leads one to think: names do matter, and in a way that you may not imagine. Yes, this is correlation, this is not causation. But if I had two resumes—one from a Deepti Shah and one from a Manikandan—and both of them had taken the class 10 exams in roughly the same year, and I don't know their marks, **I know exactly whom I’m going to pick because if I’m going to use marks as a basis, there’s a 40 percentage point difference on average between these two names. Names do matter**.

**Anand**: [03:52] And while we were counting names, I found something strange. I saw that, for example, the number of times Manikandan was mentioned versus Priya was mentioned; Manikandan was 16% higher. This is a different year, okay? And then between Priya and Vignesh, there’s a 15% difference, 13% difference between the next, 18%, 18%, 15%. They’re hovering around the same number. In fact, it looks like a very steady number, and it turns out that if you plot this on a log-log scale, you will get a perfectly straight line or something very close to a straight line, which is unusual. Now, **why is it that the most common name is as much more common than the second most common name, as the second is compared to the third, as the third is compared to the fourth, and so on?**

**Anand**: [04:30] And this is not unusual. When we did this for elections, looked at all of the candidate names in assembly elections, we find that it’s also, again, almost a perfectly straight line. There were 629 candidates with the name "None of the Above"—ignore that, that's a data artifact. Om Prakash 478, Ashok Kumar 411, Ram Singh 362, and the ratios are almost steady. Strange. But at this point you probably wonder, wait a second, what? 478 Om Prakashes?

**Anand**: [05:01] I mean, there are—that's almost close to the number of constituencies, right? So I mean, wouldn't there be duplicate candidate names? Well, actually, this is across all of the elections, so it’s not that bad. But it turns out that there hasn't been a single election since the 1991 elections where there have been duplicate candidate names until 2014, this election, where we did have duplicate candidate names. **Turns out that there were 11 candidates named Chandulal Sahu in Mahasamund**. 11 candidates, exactly the same name. Five Lakhan Lal Sahus in Bilaspur, three Jarnail Singhs in West Delhi. In fact, there were also two Hema Malinis contesting from Mathura—one obviously is *the* Hema Malini, but one is obviously not. **And all of these incidentally were sitting MPs, which means that this is clearly a strategy by opposition to confuse the voters to voting for the wrong candidate**.

**Anand**: [05:58] And these are the parties that the sitting MPs belonged to. You'll notice that one party is conspicuous by its absence. I will say no more.

**Anand**: [06:17] But speaking of which, you know, I mean, these names—we were once looking at how often candidates with the same names are causing a problem. And for that, we were looking at elections across various states. So in Tamil Nadu, for instance, we were looking at the elections and sizing the number of candidates in each of these elections. So each circle represents one constituency in Tamil Nadu. This is Madurantakam, for instance, where in this one election there were 90 candidates that stood for elections. 90! Which means that you have to go through a fairly large ballot sheet to find their name.

**Anand**: [06:53] But it continued. In 1991, there were two constituencies, Pallipattu and Arakkonam, where there were almost 250 candidates standing for the same elections. Which means that it's not a ballot sheet; it’s a ballot booklet that you have to flip through. And in 1996, there is Modakkurichi with 1,033 candidates. Not a booklet; it’s a book. It’s probably the telephone directory of Modakkurichi. Now, here what we found was that the names of the candidates looked like this. **So if you are a Palanisamy K., I mean, how do you figure out which Palanisamy K. you are to vote for yourself?** Which seems to have been a problem because 88 candidates stood for elections and got zero votes, meaning they didn't even vote for themselves.

**Anand**: [07:44] Let’s get back to names. Now, this is common in many areas. Bollywood as well. If you look at the credits across all movies, you will find that Lata Mangeshkar is mentioned much more often than Asha Bhosle is mentioned much more often than Shakti Kapoor than Kishore Kumar and so on. And this is almost again a straight line. **Why is this? Turns out that there is a phenomenon called preferential attachment. Popularity feeds on itself**. The more popular the name, the more people want the child to be named that way. I mean, once Shah Rukh Khan’s son was named Aryan, you know that popularity of Aryan just shoots up, right? But the thing is that something that is more popular tends to attract more popularity. **So what's terrible is that not only was some of my fate determined when I was named Anand, it’s even worse that my parents probably didn't have that much of a say in choosing it; it was probably common or popular enough or a growing name, which means that my fate was sealed even before they had decided**.

**Anand**: [08:35] But is this unique to names, this whole preferential attachment kind of thing? What about marks? So we said, "Look, I’m counting names; I may as well count marks also and see how they’re distributed." So when we looked at the Tamil Nadu marks distribution for English, we found that it’s roughly a normal curve. So this is a graph of the number of students who got zero marks, one mark, two marks, 10 marks, and so on. And it’s roughly a normal curve—very few students get high marks, very few students get low marks. **But suddenly there is a huge number of students getting exactly 35 marks**.

**Anand**: [09:03] Okay, very kind English teachers who say that, "I will take some of the students who would have just about failed and move them on." But we noticed that that’s not uniform. There are still students who fail at 34, which means that there are some English teachers who say, "No, you will fail at 34, why should I?" So at least in English, there’s room for prayer in the morning, right? Hope that your paper gets corrected by the right teacher. **But you don’t need to pray in Social Science**. Now, the education department said, "Look, we swear we have no official policy on moderation." Whatever is happening, the teachers are getting together and doing it, and for some reason, the English teachers haven't got their act together. But in Social Science, you don't need to pray. You're set for life. Same for Mathematics. Okay, you don’t need to worry about Mathematics. **And interestingly, this graph actually, I had cut it off for consistency; otherwise, it goes on beyond the ceiling**.

**Anand**: [09:51] The other anomaly in Mathematics is this: there’s a spike at 100. And a lot of people said, "Yeah, yeah, see, Mathematics is objective. The teachers can give 100 because they know that the answers are correct and they can justify the answer." But when we dug further, that didn't seem to be the case. And we did a lot of research and found—there’s a lot of literature behind this—that said that **Mathematics is one of those subjects that is bimodal**. There are some people that get it, and there are some people that don’t. And what’s happening is that the ones that get it are the equivalent of a class 12 student taking a class 10 exam. They would have comfortably scored 110, 120, and because the exam doesn’t give you more than 100, you’re just getting squeezed in here.

**Anand**: [10:29] Right. So which means that there’s another reason why there is this spike here. And part of this—not a part of this—a reasonably strong portion of this mathematical ability is actually determined at birth. **So which means that not only was I stuck with a name, I was also potentially stuck with an ability that helped or hindered, as the case may be**. What else makes a difference at birth? What else are we stuck with? Gender? Not much we can do about it usually.

**Anand**: [10:58] So quick question: how many people think boys score more than girls? Raise your hands. Okay, two hands. Brave hands that went up. Two boys' hands that went up. How many people think girls score more? Okay, practically everyone else. Yeah, yeah, you’re right. I mean, see, the only thing that makes a difference is in where do they score more and how much more—that’s the only question, right? So in Physics and Chemistry, the difference is not too huge, but **when it comes to Accounting, Commerce, and Economics, the difference is huge**.

**Anand**: [11:26] Now, there are other reasons also for this. It turns out that the girls' dropout ratio is actually higher, which means that the smarter girls are more likely to stay back in class. Differences in the early stages tend to be lower; it expands. But there is also evidence even at the early stages to show that there is a difference—not as large, not as statistically significant, but still reasonable. **So gender’s not something you can choose either**.

**Anand**: [11:49] What about the place of birth? So we did a quick analysis of marks in Karnataka and found two things: one, if you’re born in the Hyderabad-Karnataka region, you’re in trouble. In fact, if you’re born anywhere away from the coast, your marks tend to dip. **And this is true across states: coastal areas consistently tend to do better**. And this is for the same reason that we saw that the name makes a difference. The coastal areas are better off economically and have been so for a very long time, and the students who study there also tend to do better. So where you’re born makes a difference as well.

**Anand**: [12:19] What about when you’re born? Does your birthday make a difference? So we said, "Look, birthdays at least ought to be random, right?" I mean, so we took all of the births in the US and said that should be equally distributed. So 15 years' worth of US birth data, and this is how they’re distributed. From January to December, from the 1st of the month to the 31st of the month. **It turns out that it’s not uniform. There are a huge number of births in the second half of September**. Most conceptions happened during the winter holiday seasons; nine months later is when the kids are born. This phenomenon has a name; they’re called "winter babies."

**Anand**: [12:54] Not just that, you’ll notice that there are very few births during the Christmas holidays, the Thanksgiving holidays, the New Year holidays, their Independence Day holidays. This half reads like a holiday calendar, not a birth calendar. Which again can be explained. See, a high proportion of births are C-section births, which means that the doctors and hospitals when they’re short-staffed, they say, "Can we move this around a little bit?" And you have relatively fewer births on holidays. There are fewer births on Sundays also.

**Anand**: [13:20] But let’s not be so quick to blame just the doctors and hospitals. Notice that there’s this light stripe on the 13th of every month? Superstition. You don’t want your kids to be born on the 13th of the month—unlucky day. You don’t want your kids to be born on April Fool’s Day either. But Feb 14th, Valentine’s Day, that’s a great day for a kid to be born on; let’s push them all there.

**Anand**: [13:45] So if the US is this superstitious, what’s India like? So we started asking the question also before we got to India. See, now if birthdays aren't random, now is this numerology stuff for real? Is this astrology stuff for real? So you know, maybe I should be born in Virgo or whatever. And all of the scientifically-minded people that I spoke to said, "Nah, what rubbish, what rubbish." I'm a scientifically-minded person too. I said, "What rubbish."

**Anand**: [14:09] **And I found that if you plot the average marks of students born on different months, June-born score the lowest, September-born score the highest**. And this is a huge difference. There’s a 120 marks out of 1,200, ten percentage point difference between these. In fact, there’s only one other factor that I saw that had a larger difference, and that was whether the student was SC/ST or not. Other than that, this is huge. You say, "Wait, okay, was 2011 an odd year?" We repeated it. 2009, same pattern. 2010, same pattern. Every year from 2005 to 2016—same pattern. Every district, every state. Class 10 versus Class 12. Every subject. Any which way you slice and dice it. Boys versus girls. However you want to do it.

**Anand**: [14:48] And some of you have probably seen or have guessed what I’m talking about. **This is the same phenomenon that Malcolm Gladwell talks about in *Outliers*, where children born in the months of January, February, and March tend to make the Canadian junior hockey team**. Why? Because their selection cutoff is that you need to be eight years old as of 1st January. So the January-borns just miss the cutoff, join the next year where they’re almost a full year older than the youngest in the batch and are better built physically, more mature emotionally, play better hockey, football, and tend to be the ones that get selected in the national team.

**Anand**: [15:23] Schools in Tamil Nadu open in July. The June-borns just make the cutoff and are the youngest in the batch. The August-September borns just miss the cutoff and end up joining the next year and are typically the oldest in the class. So you’d say, "Wait a second, the education system should have bridged this gap, right?" **Turns out that this difference is only five percentage points in Class 6, and it expands to ten percentage points by the time it’s Class 12. So the education system is actually amplifying this difference**.

**Anand**: [15:47] So we said, "Okay, but what about the births pattern? Hopefully, at least that’s random, so we don’t have much control about it. Or are we like the US and are we doing stuff around this?" Turns out that we are. **Turns out that none of the Indian parents have children in August**. Not quite, not quite. Of course, children are born in August. But remember that we have as Indians a very different option: we can choose what the birthday is going to be as far as admissions are concerned, can’t we? So all of these admissions in the first half of June, the second half of May—and I’m not saying that these are faked just because of the birthdays. **Look at these dark stripes on the 5th, 10th, 15th, 20th, 25th. When people cook up numbers, they cook up round numbers**.

**Anand**: [16:36] So much easier to say 15th. My father’s actual birthday is December the 21st; his official birthday: June the 15th. Get into school earlier. **And this has an impact on their marks because if you overlay the marks of these children, you’ll find that the children who say they’re born on the 5th, the 10th, the 15th, the 20th, etc., they tend to score lower because these are younger kids who’ve been squeezed back into an earlier date and we have trouble**.

**Anand**: [16:56] So when you’re born makes a difference, and that’s not really in your control. So what all affects your marks? We did a study, we took NCERT data and looked at pretty much every single parameter that looks at—that potentially has an influence in the child's marks. **And we find that the top four factors that make a difference: father’s education, father’s occupation, mother’s education, mother’s occupation**.

**Anand**: [17:20] Now, there’s a slight variation across states. If you go to Punjab, for example, which is far more patriarchal, the mother has a much larger influence. If you go to a matriarchal state like West Bengal, the father has a larger influence. But there’s no place where one of these four parameters is not the number one factor. And every other behavioral aspect—how often you play—**it turns out that the more you play, the better you do in Mathematics, but the worse you do when it comes to English**. When you watch more TV, you do better in English, but you do worse in Mathematics. So depending on whether you want your kids to be, I don't know, journalists versus engineers, you can decide whether you send them out to play or get them to watch TV.

**Anand**: [17:56] **But all of these are secondary to the two primary factors, which are who your parents are and what they’re doing**. Which means that in our own small ways, **we are prisoners of our birth**. How we are called by our parents—that makes a difference. What skills we’re good at is something we’re born with. What gender we’re born at makes a difference. Where we’re born, when we’re born, whom we’re born to—all of these are factors that truly influence our lives. We live in an age that is scientific. We live in an era where we have the ability to move forward with almost no barriers. But at this same time, I would still say our birth did make a difference. Let’s be thankful for that. Thank you.
